选择与限制:生育过程中的终止妊娠措施——基于规范和实践层面的价值权衡

人口研究 ›› 2011, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (1): 93-102.

选择与限制:生育过程中的终止妊娠措施——基于规范和实践层面的价值权衡

湛中乐

北京大学宪法与行政法研究中心，北京 100871

出版日期:2011-01-29 发布日期:2012-11-18
通讯作者: zzl@pku.edu.cn
作者简介:湛中乐, 法学博士, 北京大学宪法与行政法研究中心副主任、法学院教授, 博士生导师

Choice and Restriction of Abortion in the Reproductive Process:Balance of Values in Terms of Norms and Practices

Zhan Zhongle

Law School of Peking University, Beijing 100871

Online:2011-01-29 Published:2012-11-18
Contact: zzl@pku.edu.cn
About author:Professor,Law School of Peking University

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 终止妊娠问题在规范层面一是作为对于违反计划生育规定生育子女的行为所采取的纠正措施之一而存在的;二是对基于非医学需要性别鉴定/选择的终止妊娠的禁止,但存在当事人终止妊娠的动机难以确定、控制性别比例的初衷难以实现、对符合生育条件的妇女与不符合生育条件的妇女区别对待、缺乏设定行政许可的上位法依据等问题。在实践层面上,选择性别的终止妊娠未得到真正禁止。规范与实践层面问题背后的出路在于厘清问题所涉及到的权利冲突,并对其进行价值权衡。

关键词: 生育过程, 终止妊娠, 规范和实践, 权利冲突, 价值权衡

Abstract: Normatively abortion is a remedy measure in family planning policies,while sex-selective abortions are prohibited.However,the prohibition encounters many problems including the difficulty of confirming the motivation of abortion and attaining the purpose for gender balance,the different treatment between women in compliance with the family planning polices and those violating the polices,and the absence of upper law setting for administrative licensing.In practice,sex-selective abortions have not been genuinely forbidden.Solutions to these problems lie in clearing the conflicts of rights of different subjects and balancing the values of these rights.

Keywords: Reproductive Process, Abortion, Norms and Practices, Conflicts of Rights, Balance of Values

湛中乐. 选择与限制:生育过程中的终止妊娠措施——基于规范和实践层面的价值权衡[J]. 人口研究, 2011, 35(1): 93-102.

Zhan Zhongle. Choice and Restriction of Abortion in the Reproductive Process:Balance of Values in Terms of Norms and Practices[J]. Population Research, 2011, 35(1): 93-102.

[1]	. 治理出生人口性别比失衡问题为何成效甚微?——福建省泉州市综合治理工作的实践与思考[J]. 人口研究, 2006, 30(1): 84-88.
[2]	江中三. 综合治理出生人口性别比问题亟待完善相关立法[J]. 人口研究, 2005, 29(2): 91-95.
[3]	高元祥. 我国人口与计划生育法的几个理论问题[J]. 人口研究, 2001, 25(5): 76-80.